Tag Archives: lieutenant governor

VCU Poll Questioned

By Jim Ellis — Friday, Sept. 12, 2025

Polling

The L. Douglas Wilder School of Government and Public Affairs at Virginia Commonwealth University just released a new statewide survey that may spur more questions than it answers.

The poll (Aug. 18-28; 804 Virginia adults; 764 registered Virginia voters; live interview) finds the Democratic candidates sweeping the Republicans in the three statewide offices of Governor, Lieutenant Governor, and Attorney General. While such a result is certainly conceivable in what has become a relatively reliable blue state, the methodology involved may suggest a high inaccuracy factor.

While the ballot test figures seem to be reasonably in line with regard to the Governor’s race, the Lieutenant Governor and Attorney General conclusions seem a bit out of balance.

In the ballot tests, former Rep. Abigail Spanberger (D) leads Lt. Gov. Winsome Earle-Sears (R), 48-39 percent, state Sen. Ghazala Hashmi (D-Richmond) tops John Reid (R) by a closer 44-40 percent split, and former state Delegate Jay Jones (D) moves ahead of incumbent Attorney General Jason Miyares (R), 46-40 percent.

Republican Lieutenant Governor candidate Reid has largely been abandoned by his party’s leadership. Gov. Glenn Youngkin (R) even tried to remove him from the ticket. Therefore, we see little in the way of campaign activity coming from this GOP nominee. Yet, he is the best performer among Republicans according to this poll.

The person who has typically come forward as the strongest, incumbent Attorney General Jason Miyares, is down beyond the polling margin of error in this VCU study. Other polls have shown the race to be tight, and even with Democrat Jones ahead, but Miyares has been aggressive on the campaign trail and is making a major effort. Therefore, this ballot test result appears at least somewhat surprising.

The poll has methodological flaws. First, the sampling period is a full 10 days, which is much longer than the typical three-day polling period that is the industry standard for live interview surveys. The long sampling period tends to skew final results because the political situation can change in a relatively short number of days.

In a two-question series where respondents are asked with which political party do they identify, 34 percent said Democratic, 33 percent Republican, and 29 percent classified themselves as Independent. This break suggests a skew toward the Republicans because Democratic identification in Virginia, even though it is not a party registration state, should be more robust than leading Republicans by only one preference percentage point.

The follow up question sheds further light upon the party swings. Querying those who called themselves Independents, identified with a minor party, refused to answer the question, or simply said they didn’t know, the pollsters attempted to determine with which party they feel closest. Here, we see a much different split of 38 percent Democratic, 28 percent Republican, and 23 percent saying neither. This corrects the skew of the original question and brings the full electorate’s predisposition into a more realistic perspective.

The poll badly skews toward the older voter. While 29.2 percent of the Virginia population is over 55 years old, in the VCU poll this same age demographic accounts for 55.8 percent of the responses. Thus, despite the Republican candidates performing better with this age segment than their statewide numbers and seeing this demographic account for a strong majority of the responses suggests the weighting factor skewed significantly in favor of the Democratic candidates.

Another skew relates to the income segment. In the survey sample, 48 percent of those answering the income question are in the $100,000 and over range for household income. Approaching 28 percent of the universe responded with over $150,000 annual household income. Yet, the statistics indicate that only 32 percent of Virginia households are actually in this category. The upper income skew within this sample heavily favors the Democratic candidates.

With the election moving quickly into political prime time, we can expect to see a great many new polls released. Understanding the weighting methods of each will help determine a more accurate picture of where the electorate will head on November 4th.

Republican Youngkin Notches First Lead in Virginia Gubernatorial Race

By Jim Ellis

Republican Glenn Youngkin, Virginia candidate for governor

Sept. 24, 2021 — A new University of Mary Washington survey (conducted by Research America, Sept. 7-13; 1,000 total sample 528 likely Virginia gubernatorial election voters, live interview & online) finds Republican Glenn Youngkin (R) leading former Virginia Gov. Terry McAuliffe (D), 48-43 percent, but there are caveats.

While virtually every poll has projected the two candidates recording support percentages in the 40s, this is the first that found the ex-governor and former Democratic National Committee chairman trailing. Two other surveys were also released yesterday, and both of them find results consistent with other pollsters that place both candidates in the 40s, but with McAuliffe holding the advantage.

KAConsulting (Sept. 17-19; 700 likely Virginia voters, live interview), polling for the Presidential Coalition, found McAuliffe topping Youngkin, 46-42 percent. Public Policy Polling (Sept. 17-18; 875 Virginia voters, interactive voice response system) derived an almost identical 45-42 percent McAuliffe ballot test result during a simultaneous time realm.

The Mary Washington study may well be an outlier. While the 48-43 percent margin comes from those describing themselves as likely voters in the Nov. 2 election, when responses from all 1,000 sampled individuals are recorded, the ballot test flips to 43-38 percent in favor of McAuliffe. It is not unusual to see differences when screening for likely voters versus the universe as a whole, but detecting a ten-point swing affecting just one candidate – you will notice McAuliffe scores 43 percent within both groups – raises methodological questions.

The poll becomes even more suspect when seeing that the candidates in the other statewide races, lieutenant governor and attorney general, produce no such GOP swing. In the lieutenant governor’s contest, Republican Winsome Sears has a 47-41 percent lead over Democrat Hala Ayala among likely voters, but the two are dead even at 38 percent support when all respondents are added to the ballot test matrix.

In the AG’s campaign among likely voters, Republican Jason Miyares holds a 46-42 percent edge over incumbent Democrat Mark Herring, but the race flips to 40-37 percent in the attorney general’s favor when all respondents are questioned.

Continue reading →

South Carolina’s Political Conundrum

By Jim Ellis

Jan. 20, 2017 — Gov. Nikki Haley’s (R) confirmation hearing to become US Ambassador to the United Nations and an expected quick Senate approval vote will ignite a rather unique South Carolina constitutional and political situation. Tangentially, the evolving lieutenant governor office quandary also has an effect upon the upcoming special congressional election in the state’s 5th District, to occur once incumbent Rep. Mick Mulvaney (R-Lancaster/Rock Hill) is confirmed as Office of Management & Budget director.

When Gov. Haley resigns to accept the UN position, Lt. Gov. Henry McMaster (R) will immediately ascend to the governorship. Under the state’s constitution, at least until right after the 2018 election, the Senate President Pro Tempore, a powerful legislative leader, automatically becomes lieutenant governor. In this situation, however, the sitting President Pro Tem does not want to be lieutenant governor, preferring to keep his Senate post.

Hugh Leatherman (R-Florence), who is 85 years old and is a 36-year veteran state senator, has little interest in relinquishing his more powerful leadership position in exchange for a largely ceremonial statewide office. His problem, however, is that the state Supreme Court just ruled that he has no choice. According to the Court’s directive, Leatherman, or whoever sits in the Senate Pro Tem’s office, must fill an open lieutenant governor’s office.

Continue reading →

Texas Results: Hall Falls, Dewhurst Crushed

Venerable Rep. Ralph Hall (TX-4-R), who at 91 years of age is the oldest member in the history of the House of Representatives, lost his bid for a 19th term last night in the Texas Republican run-off. Hall becomes the first federal incumbent to lose a bid for renomination during this election cycle. Fifty-two other senators and representatives of both parties have been renominated in the early primaries against competition of varying strength.

Former US Attorney John Ratcliffe (R) scored a 53-47 percent victory last night after holding Hall to 46 percent in the primary election. True to form, when an incumbent is forced to a run-off, he or she invariably loses. In this case, because Hall had received endorsements from the losing candidates in the March 4 Texas primary and was drawing renewed respect for his longevity of service, and that he is the last remaining World War II veteran in Congress, many believed he had the opportunity and ability to reverse the normal post-primary electoral trend. But, such was not to be.

As is typical in Texas nominating elections, turnout was extremely low, only 42,139  Continue reading >

Election Day Outlook

Voters in many states go to the polls tomorrow to fill municipal offices and, in a pair of instances, statewide positions and legislatures. Kentucky and Mississippi will elect governors. Virginia’s Senate elections will have a major effect upon that state’s congressional redistricting plan, scheduled to be drawn in the new legislative session beginning in January.

In the Blue Grass State, Gov. Steve Beshear (D) is headed for a landslide re-election, as polls show him consistently above 50 percent and more than 20 points in front of state Senate President David Williams. The Democrats are in position to capture all statewide offices there.

To the south, the Republicans are likely to sweep the political board in Mississippi, with the exception of the race for attorney general, as Lt. Gov. Phil Bryant (R) is poised to win a big victory against Hattiesburg Mayor Johnny DuPree (D).

In the Virginia Senate, Democrats hold a 22-18 majority. Gov. Bob McDonnell (R) is only at the mid-point of his single term in office, therefore he is not on the ballot tomorrow. The 100-member state House of Delegates will remain safely in GOP hands. The state Senate redistricting plan is what the Democratic leadership wanted, but it still appears the GOP has a chance to reclaim the majority. Since the Republicans control the lieutenant governor’s office, losing just two net seats will cost the Democrats their power position and give the GOP full control of the state government. Under the Commonwealth’s constitution, the lieutenant governor, in this case Republican Bill Bolling, would cast any tie-breaking vote. Several seats are in play making such a scenario a strong possibility.

Ohio voters will have a chance to affirm Gov. John Kasich’s (R) legislative initiative to curtail public employee collective bargaining rights and a significant reduction in benefits. Polls indicate the pro-referendum group has the advantage going into the election.

Turning to the west, one U.S. House congressional vacancy will take a step toward fulfillment tomorrow in Oregon as each party will choose nominees to replace resigned Rep. David Wu (D-OR-1). On the Democratic side, late polling gives state Sen. Susan Bonamici a wide lead over state Labor Commissioner Brad Avakian and state Rep. Brad Witt. Rob Cornilles, the 2010 GOP candidate who lost to Wu 42-55 percent, is the prohibitive favorite for the Republicans. The special general election will be held Jan. 31, with tomorrow’s Democratic winner assuming the favorite’s track to win the seat.

Tomorrow will bring us some answers and allow us to ask new questions, one of which will undoubtedly pertain to what effect, if any, the votes cast tomorrow will have on the 2012 election. It is already clear that parallels will be drawn.