Sen. Patrick Leahy’s Retirement Could Create a Domino Effect of 0pen Seats

Vermont Sen. Patrick Leahy (D)

By Jim Ellis

Nov. 17, 2021 — Vermont Sen. Patrick Leahy (D), the Senate President Pro Tempore and fifth longest-serving senator in American history, announced Monday that he would not seek a ninth term next year.

The decision was a surprise in that few expected the senator to do anything but run despite some cryptic comments he made earlier in the year. Sen. Leahy will retire as the chairman of the Senate Appropriations Committee after previously heading both the Agriculture and Judiciary Committees. He came to national prominence as the 10-year Judiciary Committee chairman.

As the Chittendon County State’s Attorney, Leahy first ran for the Senate as a little known underdog and was able to win a close general election in the Watergate year of 1974. In those days, Vermont was a Republican state. He was then re-elected in 1980, ’86, ’92, ’98, 2004, ’10, and ’16. Over his long electoral career, he averaged 60.6 percent of the vote over the eight elections.

During all of that time, he had one close call after his original victory, beating Republican Stewart Ledbetter by 2,755 votes in his first re-election during the 1980 campaign cycle. After that, in only one contest did he drop below 60 percent.

In his first election, with a combined vote on the Democratic and Independent Vermonters ballot lines, he was able to defeat Republican Richard Mallary and Bernie Sanders, the latter of whom drew 4.1 percent of the vote on the Liberty Union Party ticket.

After a string of Republican senators exiting, five in all with two more — Sens. Ron Johnson (R-WI) and John Thune (R-SD) — not yet revealing their 2022 political plans, Sen. Leahy becomes the first in-cycle Democrat not to seek re-election. The five departing Republicans are Richard Shelby (AL), Roy Blunt (MO), Richard Burr (NC), Rob Portman (OH), and Pat Toomey (PA).

Vermont, however, is unlikely to become a competitive open seat. Eight-term at-large Rep. Peter Welch (D-Norwich), who has the same constituency as a senator, is well positioned to succeed Sen. Leahy and is expected to soon announce his candidacy.

Already, Gov. Phil Scott (R), clearly the Republicans’ best hope to put the seat in play, announced through a spokesman that he continues to have no interest in running for the federal post. Former Gov. Jim Douglas (R), who held Sen. Leahy to a 54-43 percent victory in 1992, also said he will not run for the Senate. The same for 2020 Democratic gubernatorial nominee and former Lt. Gov. David Zuckerman.

Should Rep. Welch hop into the Senate race, the potentially competitive open battle may be for the at-large House seat. Vermont, however, now being one of the most reliable of Democratic states, is not likely to elect a Republican to the House or Senate while simultaneously and repeatedly returning Scott to office as governor, even with 67 percent of the vote as he attracted a year ago.

Vermont, like New Hampshire, has two-year terms for its statewide offices. Therefore, though Gov. Scott has been elected three times, he is still only completing his fifth year in office. Aside from declining to run for the Senate, Gov. Scott has not yet indicated whether he will seek a fourth term as governor.

Though Vermont has featured non-competitive general elections for most of the last decade, things could change in 2022 with Sen. Leahy’s retirement potentially creating a domino effect of open seats. In the end, however, Democrats will almost assuredly prevail, but their victory path may be more interesting in 2022 than what we typically see.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.