By Jim Ellis — Monday, Dec. 22, 2025
Wyoming Senate
Wyoming first-term Sen. Cynthia Lummis (R)
The Lummis decision means there are nine open US Senate seats, which is a high number in an election cycle with just over one-third of the 100-member body coming before the voters. Now, the political speculation turns toward who may run to replace Sen. Lummis.
Already at issue is whether Gov. Mark Gordon (R) will make a move to challenge the state’s two-term limit law. Based upon a legal flaw, attorneys and analysts believe that challenging the law in court would be successful. Therefore, Gov. Gordon may have a chance of running for a third term. It remains to be seen if the Lummis retirement influences his decision.
Most believe the Governor will not seek re-election and probably is not inclined to run for the Senate. With the candidate filing deadline not until May 29 for the Aug. 18 primary, much time remains to make political decisions.
Wyoming is arguably the most Republican state in the country, at least as President Trump is concerned. In the past two presidential elections, the Equality State was Trump’s best-performing domain with an average vote percentage of 70.3. In 2016, Wyoming giving him 67.4 percent of its votes was his second-best state behind only West Virginia. Therefore, the eventual US Senate Republican nominee will become a prohibitive favorite to hold the seat for the party in the general election.
This brings us to at-large Rep. Harriet Hageman (R-Cheyenne). The conventional Wyoming political wisdom suggested that if Gordon retired, Rep. Hageman would run for Governor, and the most contested political battle would be the open race to replace her in the House.
Now, should Gov. Gordon retire, Rep. Hageman could choose among entering the open Governor’s race, the open Senate campaign, or simply seeking re-election. The odds are strong that she would be a heavy favorite to win whichever contest she selects with a major open-seat Republican primary battle ensuing for the other two statewide posts.
NY Governor
On Friday, New York Rep. Elise Stefanik (R-Schuylerville) announced that she will discontinue her campaign for Governor and retire from the House at the end of the current Congress. The latter decision does not change the open-seat count because she was already relinquishing the congressional seat to enter the gubernatorial campaign.
Toward the end of last week, Siena College released their New York statewide poll (Dec. 8-12; 801 registered New York voters; live interview & online) that finds Gov. Kathy Hochul (D) re-establishing a strong lead over both Rep. Stefanik and Nassau County Executive Bruce Blakeman (R).
Against Rep. Stefanik, Siena sees the current Governor leading 49-30 percent. Polling results such as this, and assuming the Stefanik campaign internal data is producing similar totals, is likely a major factor in the Congresswoman’s decision to end her statewide bid.
In the battle for Rep. Stefanik’s open House seat, Democrats already have one candidate who has been campaigning for the better part of the year. When the Congresswoman was the President’s original nominee for US Ambassador to the United Nations, and it appeared a replacement special election would be called in CD-21, the district’s Democratic county chairs chose dairyman Blake Gendebien as their nominee.
Though holding a special election became unnecessary, Gendebien continued his campaign and reported having just over $2 million in his campaign account according to the Sept. 30 campaign financial disclosure report. Gendebien now has three Democratic opponents for the regular election, the most serious of whom appears to be former Deputy Assistant US Trade Rep. Dylan Hewitt.
On the Republican side, the current two top contenders are state Assemblyman Robert Smullen (R-Mohawk Valley) and businessman Anthony Constantino, who has already loaned his campaign $2 million.
New York’s 21st District occupies almost the entire land area of the state’s northeastern sector. According to the Dave’s Redistricting App statisticians, the partisan lean is 52.1R – 44.6D, which certainly gives the eventual Republican nominee an edge but also suggests the general election could turn competitive.